I’m a Fiend for Horror and Westerns. Netflix Has One of the Best Genre Mashups Ever Made

Father’s Day is coming up and, if you’re like me, you’re searching for the perfect movie to watch on the big day. Well, as a dad myself, I can easily find comfort in the tried and true classics like National Lampoon’s Vacation, Once Upon a Time in America or even The Shawshank Redemption. 

There’s no arguing that those titles are stereotypical “dad” movies. 

But I’m not a stereotypical dad. My cinematic tastes usually lead me down an alternate path. Yes, I love me a good western but I’m also a die-hard horror movie fan. What if there was a way to blend my two favorite genres together for one epic movie night? I racked my brain and suddenly had a lightbulb moment: It’s time to hit Netflix and revisit Bone Tomahawk.

Bone Tomahawk follows four men as they venture into the desert to rescue some townspeople who were kidnapped after a surprise attack. This is no ordinary rescue mission, though. It’s revealed early on in the film that a group of savage, cave-dwelling (and potentially supernatural) cannibals is the guilty party. Defeating them will be no easy feat. 

To that point, the eventual confrontation between the men and these attackers is one of the most grizzly, violent displays I’ve ever seen in a western.

Read more: Netflix Review: Our Top Pick in a Sea of Streaming Choices

Kurt Russell plays Sheriff Hunt alongside Richard Jenkins, who plays Deputy Chicory, in the horror-western movie, Bone Tomahawk.

RLJ Entertainment

The first and probably biggest draw here is the movie’s stellar cast. Kurt Russell leads the charge as Sheriff Franklin Hunt, alongside Patrick Wilson as Arthur O’Dwyer, Richard Jenkins (the Oscar-nominated actor for The Shape of Water) as Deputy Chicory and Lost alum Matthew Fox as John Brooder. Supporting players include Lily Simmons, Zahn McLarnon, David Arquette, horror icon Sid Haig, Fred Malamed, Michael Paré, and Sean Young. 

Tombstone is hands down one of my favorite westerns, and seeing Russell get back on the horse, so to speak, to lead another western (The Hateful Eight, which he also stars in, hit theaters the same year) is reason in and of itself to watch this movie. As wonderful as he is in the role of Sheriff Hunt, the movie gives enough scenery to chew for Wilson, Jenkins, and Fox — each actor delivers nuanced performances that keep things grounded, even as the stakes are steadily raised.

An extra tip of the hat should be given to Fox, the enigmatic standout. Brooder is not a likable character, yet his ego doesn’t define who this man is either. His drive to hunt down these attackers stems from a deeply personal trauma that earns him equal parts disdain from the audience and empathy. Without him, the crew probably wouldn’t make it as far as they do.

Matthew Fox plays the armed gentleman John Brooder in the horror-western Bone Tomahawk.

Screenshot by Aaron Pruner/CNET

This is S. Craig Zahler’s directorial debut. He is the filmmaker behind the brutal festival darlings Dragged Across Concrete and Brawl in Cell Block 99 so if you’re at all familiar with those movies, you’d be unsurprised by the final act’s blood-spilling. Zahler also wrote the movie, which is important to note, considering how sharp the dialogue is. This is probably the key detail that brought this epic cast to the project. 

Hunt and his men spend most of the movie searching, which is not dissimilar to how John Wayne and his Texas Rangers were in John Ford’s cinematic classic, The Searchers. That iconic Western is most assuredly beloved by dads nationwide; Ford’s work has inspired filmmakers from Spielberg to Scorsese and Kurosawa.

Ford’s movies had a specific pacing that has all but disappeared from modern entertainment. His movies took their time, following characters through a slow-burn hero’s journey. This allowed the story world to sit in silence, allowing the viewer to take in the dusty horizon as if it were a photograph or painting come to life. 

Like Jim Jarmusch’s Dead Man, which tapped into a similar narrative sensibility, Zahler gives ample room for the story, characters and surrounding world to breathe, which draws the viewer in further. There’s no musical score here, and the cinematography is seamless and straightforward. Instead of populating the movie with distracting camera maneuvers, Zahler’s debut acts almost as a stage play, which gives a matter-of-fact, rudimentary vibe to the whole thing.

On the surface, Bone Tomahawk is a revenge story. Yet, underneath, it explores humanity at a crossroads, following civilized men as they grapple with the untamed, feral elements on the other side of the desert. 

Once the men meet the villains, referred to earlier in the movie as Troglodytes, the movie crosses over from Old West homage to horror territory. The practical effects in the movie’s third act bring about a series of hard-to-watch acts of violence on the level of Eli Roth’s cannibal opus, Green Inferno. I wouldn’t call this torture porn. As visceral, gory and in-your-face things get, it’s all still justified to the story being told. 

I’ve read the criticism online about Bone Tomahawk’s depiction of Native Americans, specifically in reference to the Troglodytes. I’m not here to contest that notion. However, it’s worth noting that the movie takes place during an era where prejudice toward anyone who wasn’t white or male was indeed the norm. It could also be argued that this tribe of powerful cannibals isn’t really Native American at all. That’s the sentiment spoken as a warning by Zahn McClarnon’s professor to Hunt and crew. 

Patrick Wilson, Richard Jenkins and Kurt Russell as Arthur O’Dwyer, Deputy Chicory and Sheriff Hunt in the horror-western Bone Tomahawk.

Screenshot by Aaron Pruner/CNET

If I had a gripe with the movie, it would be the abruptness of its ending. The emotional stakes do pay off, and much blood is spilled. But I have to wonder if there was ever a plan to make a sequel, as things close in an open-ended way. A number of characters’ storylines ended as they walked off into the sunset and I, for one, would love to see this story continue in some fashion.

Bone Tomahawk is not for everyone. That said, if you’re a dad like me who yearns for some quiet time away from the family to relish in some gruesome goodies, may I suggest delving into this ultraviolet western-horror opus? Movies like these don’t come around very often. You won’t be disappointed.